Is It Possible to Stop Doubting Yourself? (Yes.) 🧠
What brain science reveals about self doubt and how to overcome it. (8min Read)
TL;DR Summary
Self-doubt isn't random: It arises as a protective response rooted in early experiences like childhood criticism, conditional love, or observing anxious caregivers.
Neuroscience matters: An overactive amygdala (your brain’s alarm), a muted prefrontal cortex (your wise advisor), and a hypervigilant anterior cingulate cortex (perfectionistic editor) perpetuate self-doubt.
At its core is fear: Specifically, the fear of rejection, failure, humiliation, and not being "enough"—creating hesitation and anxiety.
But self-doubt isn't your enemy: It’s an adaptive survival strategy that tries to protect you from pain.
Change is absolutely possible: A practical, neuroscience-backed 3-step process—Awareness, Compassion, and Micro Action—can retrain your protective parts, build new neural pathways, and transform your doubt into confidence.
Why Do You Doubt Yourself?
Do you ever find yourself doubting your decisions, talents, or even your self-worth?
You're not alone.
It’s one of the most common things I see in my clients with complex trauma.
In fact, it’s one of the core tenets of CTPSD, be it from burnout, an abusive relationship, or childhood trauma.
Self-doubt isn’t your enemy, though.
It's a misunderstood internal part of most of us, shaped by psychology, neuroscience, and even evolution.
But can you actually stop doubting yourself?
Yes, but not in the way you might expect.
Today, we’re talking about where it comes from and what you can do about it!
Let’s dive in.
What Is Self-Doubt, Really?
We all know how it shows up…
Overthinking simple decisions
Procrastination due to perfectionism
Avoiding opportunities due to fear of failure
Constantly seeking validation
These common expressions of self-doubt can subtly or overtly sabotage your growth.
But, where do these thoughts and beliefs come from?!
Self-doubt is never born in a vacuum; it has roots, and they often trace back to childhood.
Surprise, surprise.
From this perspective, self-doubt isn’t merely an inconvenience; it’s an adaptive survival strategy.
When “kid you” faces a relational threat or perceived criticism, Parts of you form protective strategies designed to keep you safe from rejection, shame, or embarrassment.
But what do these early experiences actually look like, and how do they continue to shape your life today?
Great question, let’s take a look.
Direct Criticism & Shame
Think of the enthusiastic child eagerly sharing their dream with a caregiver or loved one.
Maybe it was a big, ambitious plan to become a famous musician, writer, or astronaut.
Rather than encouragement or curiosity, the caregiver dismisses the idea with a sharp criticism or laughs off the child's dream as "unrealistic."
The emotional sting of this moment embeds itself deeply, becoming a harsh inner critic whispering warnings every time ambition arises:
"Who do you think you are to aim so high?"
"You're setting yourself up to be embarrassed."
Relational Uncertainty & Conditional Love
This one might sting for the anxious achievers out there…
Imagine a child senses that a parent's love or approval depends on performance or perfection, good grades, sports achievements, or being the "easy," compliant child.
In these households, love feels conditional, linked to achieving, behaving, and never making mistakes.
Now, in adulthood, every relationship or new opportunity triggers that old anxiety, that internalized voice cautioning:
"You must be perfect, or they'll see you're not worthy."
"If they see your flaws, they'll reject you."
Witnessing Self-Doubt in Others
Sometimes, self-doubt isn't directly inflicted upon us, it’s something we absorb by witnessing.
Imagine a parent or caregiver consistently overthinking their decisions, never trusting their gut instincts, always anxious about mistakes or missteps.
Watching this over many years, a child learns a fundamental, unconscious lesson: "Life is scary. You must constantly doubt yourself to stay safe."
As an adult, you might notice yourself replaying these same patterns of hesitation, anxiety, and overanalysis, even when logic suggests there's no reason to worry.
How Self-Doubt Gets Reinforced
These early experiences aren't just isolated moments from your past.
They plant the seeds of self-doubt, which get watered and reinforced by experiences throughout your life:
A harsh professor who mocks your ideas in front of the class.
A romantic partner who dismisses your emotional needs, making you question their legitimacy.
A workplace culture that subtly undermines your confidence, causing you to second-guess your instincts.
Layer by layer, these experiences reinforce and strengthen the protective "inner doubter."
It’s important to remember that this inner voice isn't malicious; it’s protective.
It formed to shield your younger self from unbearable hurt or rejection.
But today, that same voice can feel exhausting, limiting your potential, and blocking your progress toward meaningful goals.
Recognizing that your inner doubter is trying (albeit misguidedly) to help you is the first step toward transforming its role in your life.
Here's a thoughtful, detailed, yet easy-to-understand expanded neuroscience section for your blog—rich with metaphors, relatable stories, and practical transitions into actionable steps:
What’s Happening in Your Brain When You Doubt Yourself?
Alright, we’ve got the psychology, now it’s neuroscience time.
Have you ever wondered what's actually happening inside your brain when that familiar voice whispers, "Are you sure you can do this?"
Let’s take a look!
The Amygdala
Deep inside your brain lies a small, almond-shaped structure called the amygdala.
Think of it as your brain’s alarm system, an overly sensitive security guard whose job is to detect danger and keep you safe.
When this guard senses a potential threat like the possibility of humiliation, rejection, or failure, it pulls the fire alarm.
For example, imagine preparing to speak up in a meeting with a bold new idea.
Just as you're about to raise your hand, the amygdala activates, releasing stress chemicals and igniting fear-driven thoughts:
"Wait, what if this is a bad idea?"
"What if they judge me?"
Your body tenses, your heart rate quickens, your stomach tightens.
That alarm bell triggers an intense emotional response designed to protect you.
Prefrontal Cortex: Your Internal Advisor
While the amygdala sounds the alarm, another crucial brain region steps in: the prefrontal cortex (PFC).
Sitting just behind your forehead, the PFC is responsible for decision-making, planning, and regulating emotions.
Think of your prefrontal cortex like a wise mentor, carefully weighing options, outcomes, and consequences.
Ideally, it would calm the amygdala’s frantic alarm, gently saying:
“It's okay, I've got this. I’ve prepared, and this is a great opportunity.”
However, when we’ve experienced complex trauma or ongoing relational wounds, the connection between our amygdala (alarm) and prefrontal cortex (advisor) can weaken.
As a result, the PFC struggles to quiet the alarm, leaving you stuck in that familiar spiral of doubt, anxiety, and overthinking.
Anterior Cingulate Cortex
There’s another crucial region involved: the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC).
Think of this brain area as a meticulous editor, constantly scanning for errors or potential mistakes.
When this editor is overactive (as it often is in anxious achievers), it highlights potential problems, imperfections, or imagined missteps relentlessly.
Imagine preparing a presentation and repeatedly editing it, never feeling quite “done.”
Even small decisions become massive hurdles because your brain is obsessively checking, double-checking, and critiquing every detail.
This perfectionistic ACC, left unchecked, reinforces self-doubt, making it hard to trust your instincts and move forward confidently.
Balancing Your Inner Symphony
Self-doubt creeps in when your brain’s orchestra gets thrown off balance.
This could be due to complex trauma, harsh relational experiences, or prolonged stress.
When this happens, one instrument becomes too loud, drowning out the others.
Usually, it’s the amygdala and ACC turning up the volume, flooding your system with doubt, fear, and hesitation, silencing the calm voice of your wise advisor.
Can We Really Rebalance the Brain?
The good news: your brain is incredibly adaptive and responsive to change.
Imagine your brain as a forest with well-worn hiking trails.
Right now, your “self-doubt” trail is wide, familiar, and easy to follow.
Your brain automatically travels this path whenever uncertainty arises.
But with intention, patience, and repeated practice, you can gradually create new trails, new neural pathways, that help you move through uncertainty differently, with confidence and clarity.
What’s Really at the Root of Your Self-Doubt?
Great, I get the psychology and neuroscience, but what’s really at the root of this, Cody?
Love it, let’s find out.
If we pause and examine the layers we've uncovered, so far, we see one common thread weaving it all together: Fear.
Not just any fear, though.
It's a fear rooted in vulnerability.
The fear of being hurt, judged, rejected, or simply not being "enough."
It's the fear that whispers quietly yet insistently: "If I get this wrong, will I still be accepted? Will I still be safe?"
To better understand how fear drives your self-doubt, think of it this way:
Imagine you're walking barefoot on a rocky beach.
Each step hurts, so naturally, you become hesitant, moving slowly and anxiously, uncertain about each step.
Over time, you anticipate pain before your foot even touches the ground.
Similarly, each painful experience in life—criticism, rejection, humiliation—has trained your brain to expect future pain.
The self-doubt you experience now is like that cautious anticipation, your mind trying desperately to avoid another painful step.
And because your brain is wired to protect you, it reinforces this cycle, keeping you alert, vigilant, and sometimes paralyzed by indecision.
Hopefully, you can start to see that this self-doubt, however uncomfortable, isn't your enemy.
It's a well-meaning protector, trying its best to keep you emotionally safe.
Sometimes, this cautionary voice even serves a useful purpose, urging you to prepare carefully, to reflect more deeply, to grow.
The challenge isn't to eliminate your self-doubt entirely.
Instead, it's about retraining your protective parts and your anxious brain, shifting from fear-based hesitation to confident, mindful action.
So how can you start making this shift right now?
You know I wouldn’t leave you hanging without a tool!
A 3-Step Process to Stop Doubting Yourself
This little process may seem simple, but that doesn’t mean it’s easy.
I challenge you to implement it daily for the best results!
Step 1: Awareness
Start to recognize self-doubt when it arises.
Become curious: Why am I feeling this right now?
Ask, “What Part of me is speaking right now?”
This activates your dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and brings the doubting narrative into conscious working memory, which weakens the amygdala’s urgency signal.
Step 2: Compassion
Say, “Thank you for trying to protect me. What are you afraid would happen if you relaxed?”
Validate the protective intent behind self-doubt.
Offer understanding and warmth to this part of yourself.
Say gently: “Thank you for trying to protect me, but I've got this, we’re not a kid anymore!”
Curiosity engages the ventromedial prefrontal cortex and posterior cingulate, calming the salience network and shifting you into a relaxed state.
Step 3: Rewire With Action
Take one small step forward despite the doubt.
It’s best to choose a micro action that disproves the critic’s prediction!
Then celebrate immediately to build new evidence for your competence.
Repeat this daily to reinforce healthier neural pathways, diminishing doubt’s grip.
Each successful micro action wires and fires together new neural pathways in your brain!
Transforming Your Doubt into Courage
So, is it possible to stop doubting yourself?
Yes, but not by banishing doubt entirely.
Instead, embrace and transform it.
By lovingly engaging with doubt, you create a powerful ally who reminds you of your vulnerabilities, cautioning you without controlling you.
Ultimately, it’s not about being doubt-free.
It’s about courageously moving forward with your doubt.
You don’t need to remove doubt to become confident.
True confidence is the quiet trust that you’ll be okay, no matter the outcome.
You’ve got this, there’s no doubt in my mind!
Until next time… Live Heroically 🧠
Want to Work With Me? Here Are a Few Ways I Can Help You
Download my Emotional Availability Blueprint (Free): EXACTLY how to become emotionally available to the love you've always wanted in your life.
Join the Action Academy (free): It’s the only community on earth built to help high-achieving trauma survivors get into action and out of their own way by healing the invisible baggage that secretly holds them back from the relationships, health, and success they desire.
Become a paid subscriber to the Mind, Brain, Body Lab Digest: You’ll get subscriber-only video posts, email replies, access to my entire blog archive, early access to new products, workshops & tools I create!
Supporting Research
Schwartz, R.C. (1995). Internal family systems therapy. Guilford Press.
Sapolsky, R.M. (2017). Behave: The biology of humans at our best and worst. Penguin Books.
Panksepp, J. (2004). Affective Neuroscience: The Foundations of Human and Animal Emotions. Oxford University Press.
Leary, M.R., & Guadagno, J. (2011). The Sociometer, Self-Esteem, and the Regulation of Interpersonal Behavior. In K.D. Vohs & R.F. Baumeister (Eds.), Handbook of Self-Regulation: Research, Theory, and Applications (2nd ed., pp. 339–354). Guilford Press.
Powerful post, Cody. I loved how you illustrated the different brain regions involved to help demystify our inner critic.
Great article. As always, appreciate your integration of evolutionary biology, neuroscience and parts work