Why Modern Dating Feels Like Group Therapy Without the Intimacy 🧠
How Emotional Intelligence Replaced Emotional Availability and Left Everyone Lonely (7min Read)
TL;DR Summary
Emotional Intelligence helps you understand emotions
Emotional Availability lets you be with emotions
One often develops as a survival strategy
The other requires nervous system safety
Insight without availability feels like distance
Intimacy requires presence, not just awareness
The Core Distinction Most People Miss
You can be deeply self-aware and still feel impossible to get close to.
You can name your triggers, explain your attachment style, regulate your tone, and use all the right language…
AND still leave people feeling unmet, untouched, and alone in your presence.
This is one of the most common patterns I see in the people I work with:
High emotional intelligence. Low emotional availability.
And the confusion between these two is quietly breaking a lot of hearts.
Let’s simplify this before we complicate it.
Emotional Intelligence (EI) is about cognition. Emotional Availability (EA) is about contact.
EI answers the question: “Do you understand what’s happening emotionally?”
EA answers the question: “Can you stay here with me while it’s happening?”
One builds insight. The other builds intimacy.
And intimacy is not built through explanation, it’s built through presence.
Today, we’re breaking down the differences, and by the end, you’ll know how to add some Emotional Availability to your Emotional Intelligence.
Let’s dive in!
Why EI Without EA Feels So Bad
EI-without-EA has a very specific felt sense.
People often describe it as:
Being talked about instead of met
Being understood but not held
Being analyzed instead of being accompanied (I resonate with this one)
Why?
Because language is being used as distance.
Insight becomes armor. Self-awareness becomes containment. Regulation becomes disconnection.
Not intentionally, but functionally.
One of the easiest ways to really get this is by thinking about a weather app…
Bare with me here, I promise to bring this full circle!
Emotional Intelligence is like a weather app.
It can tell you:
A storm is coming
Why it formed
How long it might last
What patterns it follows
Emotional Availability is standing outside with someone in the rain.
No explanation. No analysis.
Just: “I’m here. I feel it too. You’re not alone in this.”
Most people who overdeveloped EI skills learned early that being in the rain alone was dangerous.
So they learned to predict the weather instead.
More on this in a moment, but before we get there, I really want you to FEEL the difference between these two things because it’s a very nuanced difference.
EI vs. EA in Real Life
Let’s slow this down and make it concrete.
These examples come from my work with clients and stories I hear from my followers.
Pay close attention to the differences between the emotionally intelligent response and the emotionally available one.
1. When Someone Pulls Away
Emotionally Intelligent Response: “I’m noticing my attachment system activating. This is likely about uncertainty, so I’m choosing not to react.”
This is regulated. This is aware. This is also alone.
Emotionally Available Response: “I feel anxious, but I’m staying present. If this still matters later, I’ll tell you instead of disappearing.”
Same awareness. Different risk.
EA doesn’t mean impulsive action, it means relational presence.
2. When Someone Shares Something Vulnerable
EI: “Thank you for sharing that. I can see how that experience shaped you.”
Polite. Accurate. Closed.
EA: “That means something to me. I feel closer to you hearing that.”
EA adds contact. It lets the moment change you.
3. During Conflict
EI: “I’m staying regulated and trying not to take this personally. I understand this may be projection.”
Insightful. Detached. No bridge.
EA: “That hurt. I don’t think you meant to, but I want to talk about it with you.”
EA risks being impacted.
4. When Things Are Going Well
EI: “I’m enjoying this, but staying neutral so I don’t get attached.”
Safety through distance.
EA: “I like you. I’m letting myself feel that without clinging or running.”
Safety through capacity, VERY big difference, people.
5. Asking for Reassurance
EI: “I don’t want to place emotional demands on you. I can self-soothe.”
This often sounds virtuous, but it’s usually hyper-independence, not security.
EA: “I could use reassurance right now. Are you open to that?”
EA allows interdependence.
Yes, it puts them in a vulnerable position, but that is how intimacy is built over time!
Why So Many High-EI People Struggle With EA
Ok, Cody, but how did I become this way.
Great questions, and lemme be clear, this isn’t a character flaw.
It’s developmental.
EI often develops in environments where EA was unsafe.
Many people who excel at emotional intelligence grew up where:
Emotions were overwhelming, unpredictable, or punished
Attunement was inconsistent
Being felt was riskier than being smart
So the nervous system adapted.
The brain learned: “If I can understand emotions, I can control proximity to them.”
From a neuroscience lens:
The prefrontal cortex becomes over-relied upon
Emotional experience gets routed into cognition
The insula (interoception) and limbic system get muted or bypassed
Regulation becomes suppression with insight, not integration
This looks mature. It sounds evolved. It feels safe.
But it limits intimacy.
The Nervous System Difference Between EI and EA
Here’s the most important part of this entire blog…
Emotional Intelligence can be performed even in sympathetic activation or dorsal shutdown.
Emotional Availability requires ventral vagal safety.
EA is not a mindset. It’s a state.
You cannot think your way into it.
You have to:
Feel internal sensation
Tolerate uncertainty
Allow mutual influence
Stay present without managing the outcome
That’s why EA feels vulnerable and why it often develops after nervous system repair, not before.
This means you MUST regulate your nervous system if you want to be truly emotionally available.
Easier said than done, trust me, I’m working on this too, but it is worth it, I promise!
When these two things get mixed up:
Dating feels exhausting
Conversations feel performative
Everyone sounds “self-aware” but no one feels close
People feel evaluated instead of accompanied
Relationships stall at the insight level
Awareness without availability becomes another wall.
A very pretty wall. A very impressive wall, but… Still a wall.
Is it just me, or does this sound a lot like modern dating?
No way I would write a blog about the underlying neuroscience and psychology behind glaring cultural phenomena and issue…
That sounds so unlike me…
Speaking of being unlike me, let’s talk about what to actually DO about this.
Yes, it’s time to take some action, baby!
So, How Do You Transform EI Into EA?
This isn’t about losing insight. It’s about adding embodiment and risk.
Here are the 5 steps you need to take!
1. Notice When You’re Explaining Instead of Experiencing
Ask yourself: “Am I describing this… or am I letting it be felt?”
Shift from narrative to sensation.
2. Practice Letting Emotions Be Messy in Real Time
EA isn’t polished.
Try saying:
“I don’t fully understand this yet, but I feel something here.”
“This is vulnerable for me to say.”
“I’m nervous, and I’m staying.”
3. Allow Yourself to Be Impacted
Intimacy requires mutual influence.
Let moments land.
Let them change you slightly.
That’s availability.
4. Build Tolerance for Interdependence
Needing reassurance isn’t failure. Wanting closeness isn’t regression.
Secure attachment is not self-sufficiency, it’s flexible reliance.
Emotional availability grows when you let yourself need with someone instead of managing alone.
In practice, this looks like:
Saying “I could use reassurance right now” instead of silently self-soothing
Sharing something before you’ve fully processed it, not after
Letting someone support you even though you could handle it alone
EA isn’t about needing more, it’s about allowing need to be relational instead of private.
5. Track Nervous System Safety, Not Just Insight
Ask:
“Do I feel open or braced?”
“Am I present or managing?”
“Am I here, or observing from a distance?”
Remember, availability follows safety!
The Kind of Connection That Changes You
The goal isn’t emotional availability instead of emotional intelligence.
It’s integration.
It’s insight that stays connected. Awareness that doesn’t disappear you. Regulation that keeps you in the room.
Because intimacy isn’t built by understanding emotions from a distance.
It’s built by letting yourself be in them with someone else.
You don’t need someone who can explain feelings.
You need someone willing to experience them with you, AND the courage to be that person, too.
I believe in you, and until next time… Live Heroically 🧠
Want to Work With Me? Here Are a Few Ways I Can Help You
Apply to Becoming HER, it’s the 63-day neuroscience-backed reset that helps you finally feel calm, confident, and ready for real love again. Applications for the next small cohort are open — but not for long.
Check out my FREE webinar on The ONE Skill That Attracts Secure Love Fast. If you’re smart, attractive, successful, and self-aware, but love still feels like a minefield, this is for you!
Grab my new ebook: Exactly How to Become Emotionally Available: It’s a step-by-step guide for attracting and keeping the love you seek, built for the success but single among us!
Become a paid subscriber to the Mind, Brain, Body Lab Digest: You’ll get subscriber-only video posts, email replies, access to my entire blog archive, early access to new products, workshops & tools I create!
Supporting Research
Bowlby, J. (1988). A secure base: Parent-child attachment and healthy human development. Basic Books.
Siegel, D. J. (2012). The developing mind: How relationships and the brain interact to shape who we are. Guilford Press.
Porges, S. W. (2011). The polyvagal theory: Neurophysiological foundations of emotions, attachment, communication, and self-regulation. Norton.
Schore, A. N. (2012). The science of the art of psychotherapy. Norton.
Gross, J. J. (2015). Emotion regulation: Current status and future prospects. Psychological Inquiry, 26(1), 1–26.
Fonagy, P., Gergely, G., Jurist, E., & Target, M. (2002). Affect regulation, mentalization, and the development of the self. Other Press.
This article is educational in nature and not a substitute for therapy. If attachment wounds or relational trauma are impacting your wellbeing, working with a trauma-informed therapist can help your nervous system relearn safety in connection.